How We Rate Prop Firms
Last updated: November 5, 2026
The short version
Our rating answers one question first: will this firm actually pay you? A firm's payout record sets the typical range its rating falls in. Its rules and costs then move it up or down within that range. Every rating is set by our editor using the criteria below, and checked against the firm's own published terms.
What matters most, in order: (1) actually paying out, along with the trust and support that go with it; (2) the trading rules; (3) the cost of getting and staying funded.
Step 1: payout record sets the range
| Payout record | Typical range | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| Proven: paid by us | 4.5 – 5.0 | We have been paid by the firm, repeatedly, with no pattern of denied payouts. Only firms in this group can earn a 5.0. |
| Proven at scale | 4.0 – 4.8 | Years of verified payouts across a large trader base, with no pattern of denials. |
| Limited or unproven record | 3.0 – 4.1 | A young firm, or one without enough independent evidence that it pays. Good rules cannot make up for an unproven record. |
| Payout or trust concerns | 2.5 – 4.0 | Reports of denied payouts, unfair rules, or a suspended Trustpilot rating. |
| Do Not Trade | 2.5 or lower | Documented payout denials or other serious problems. Listed on our Do Not Trade list. |
| Closed | 0.0 | The firm has stopped operating or selling accounts. |
Step 2: rules and costs move a firm within its range
These are the most common reasons a firm loses points. The amounts are typical; how much a fact costs a firm depends on how many of its accounts it affects and how much it costs a trader in practice.
| Why a firm loses points | Typical effect |
|---|---|
| A rule that removes profit you have already made, such as voiding profits from trades held under a set number of seconds | Large; a firm with this kind of rule rates no higher than 4.0 |
| Profit split below 90/10 (for example 80/20) | −0.2 |
| News-trading restrictions on most accounts | −0.2 |
| More expensive than comparable plans at other firms | −0.1 to −0.2 |
| A low account limit (three or fewer funded accounts) | −0.1 |
| Consistency rules, activation fees or monthly billing that add real cost | −0.1 each |
Examples
- My Funded Futures, 4.4. A proven payout record at scale, but an 80/20 split instead of 90/10, news-trading restrictions on most accounts, a three-account limit, and prices above comparable plans elsewhere.
- Top One Futures, 4.0. Strong pricing and plan choice, but it removes profits on trades held under 10 seconds, which caps its rating at 4.0.
- HyperTicks, 3.9. Solid rules on paper, but no proven record of paying traders, so it stays in the limited-record range.
What a 5.0 means
A 5.0 is not given out lightly. It requires a proven payout record that we have experienced ourselves, no pattern of denied payouts, and rules and costs that don't work against traders. It is awarded by our editor, never produced by an average. Most strong firms top out at 4.8.
Sub-scores on our reviews
Each review also shows six sub-scores: Pricing & Value, Profit Split, Payout Speed, Trading Rules, Platforms & Tools, and Customer Support. They describe a firm's strengths and weaknesses. The overall rating is not their average: the payout record and the deductions above decide it.
What doesn't affect a rating
Whether a firm pays us a commission does not change its rating. Our Affiliate Disclosure explains what compensation can and cannot affect. Third-party review scores such as Trustpilot are evidence we weigh, not part of a formula.
How ratings stay current
We check every firm's promotions and prices daily, re-check its rules against its own help center and terms, and re-read its Trustpilot profile monthly. When a firm changes a rule that matters, or new evidence about its payouts appears, we review its rating. See our Editorial Standards for how we source and verify facts, and our Corrections page for fixes.
